He covers the Ballina Shire and general news on the Northern Rivers. Email from associate editor Simon Heffer to Daily Telegraph staff berating them for mistakes that appeared in the paper. 9:45am. Award winning journalist Sarah Blake is associate editor at The Saturday Telegraph and The Sunday Telegraph. Black, through his holding company Ravelston Corporation, owned 78% of Hollinger Inc. which in turn owned 30% of Hollinger International. Slip up: India lagging behind on SDGs. [75], In May 2011, the Press Complaints Commission upheld a complaint regarding The Telegraph's use of subterfuge: "On this occasion, the commission was not convinced that the public interest was such as to justify proportionately this level of subterfuge. Its investigation on the 2009 expenses scandal was named the "Scoop of the Year" in 2009, with William Lewis winning "Journalist of the Year". The Content and Native Disclosure Guidelines issued by the Internet Advertising Bureau UK (IAB) set out principles of best practice to promote continued growth in innovative areas of advertising. Editorials | Daily Telegraph Journalists Our Journalists Editorials Latest Opinion Opinion Stress is no excuse for fatally shaking a baby OUR SAY: The sentence handed down to Martin Saunders, whose 10-week-old son Ryan died after being shaken by his father, is grossly inadequate and must be appealed. [108], In January 2021 British press regulator, the Independent Press Standards Organisation ordered The Daily Telegraph to publish corrections for a "significantly misleading" article published by Toby Young in July 2020 article "When we have herd immunity Boris will face a reckoning on this pointless and damaging lockdown" which spread COVID-19 misinformation that the common cold provided "natural immunity" to COVID-19 and that London was "probably approaching herd immunity". We share brave, insightful and sometimes controversial opinions. [8] The two sister newspapers are run separately, with different editorial staff,[10] but there is cross-usage of stories. The Daily Telegraph was started by a journalist who regarded his contemporaries as elitist. Aymon Bertah is a reporter for NewsLocal, joining in early 2022 at The Dubbo News before moving to the Southern Courier in 2023. It is not known how long Wolford was there before emergency personnel were. She joined in 2021 after covering crime and courts for several mastheads throughout NSW. Derek Bishton, who by then had succeeded Rooney as editor, later wrote: "In the days before ET it would have been highly unlikely that anyone in the US would have been aware of Evans-Pritchard's work and certainly not to the extent that the White House would be forced to issue such a lengthy rebuttal. The Telegraph Media Group is a trusted and respected media brand, committed to providing journalism of the highest quality and integrity. [73] One of the judges, Robert Cauthorn, described the project as "the best deployment of blogging yet seen in any newspaper anywhere in the world". [citation needed], During the 2014 Scottish independence referendum, the paper supported the Better Together 'No' Campaign. "[44], In 2012, prior to the legalisation of same-sex marriage in the United Kingdom, Telegraph View published an editorial stating that it was a "pointless distraction" as "many [gay couples] already avail themselves of the civil partnerships introduced by Labour". Anna covered federal politics in the Canberra press gallery during the Gillard/Rudd era. [85] These had featured on its website as part of a commercial deal, but were later removed. These guiding principles outline standards of good practice which are to be observed and maintained by all employees, contractors and freelancers who provide services to the Company. Later that day, it was reported that the Barclay brothers had agreed to purchase Black's 78% interest in Hollinger Inc. for 245m, giving them a controlling interest in the company, and to buy out the minority shareholders later. [5][14] Joseph Moses Levy, the owner of The Sunday Times, agreed to print the newspaper, and the first edition was published on 29 June 1855. [115] Climate change denying journalist James Delingpole was first to use "Climategate" on his Telegraph blog for a manufactured controversy where emails were leaked from climate scientists ahead of the Copenhagen climate summit and misleadingly presented to give the appearance that the climate scientists were engaged in fraud. Easy. It is entirely appropriate, and indeed essential, that editorial staff understand and contribute to the commercial success of the Telegraph. [citation needed], When the Barclay brothers purchased the Telegraph Group for around 665m in late June 2004, Sir David Barclay suggested that The Daily Telegraph might no longer be the "house newspaper" of the Conservatives in the future. Reveal contacts of top The Daily Telegraph managers and employees. Manage your account online in MyAccount. Lauren Ferri is a general news reporter for NCA NewsWire, covering everything from breaking news and crime to politics, business and Covid-19. In March 2013 Telegraph Media Group got rid of 80 of its editorial staff and then in October last year a further 55 editorial jobs were . Uses of social media to promote a companys product or services must be clearly marked as commercial content and must comply with the CAP Code and TMG protocols. The Telegraph is an award-winning, multimedia news brand that has been synonymous with quality, authority and credibility for more than 160 years. Please include name, address, and work and home telephone numbers. Place a print or digital classified ad, funeral notice, obituary or tribute online: [117] It has published columns about the "conspiracy behind the Anthropogenic Global Warming myth",[114] described climate scientists as "white-coated prima donnas and narcissists,"[114][115] and claimed that "global warming causes about as much damage as benefits. Piers Akerman is an opinion columnist with The Sunday Telegraph. The availability of the articles online brought a large American audience to the site. Eliza Barr is the local digital reporter for the St George Shire Standard, specialising in local crime and courts. "[104], In 2016, the Hong Kong Free Press reported that The Daily Telegraph was receiving 750,000 annually to carry a supplement called 'China Watch' as part of a commercial deal with Chinese state-run newspaper China Daily. "[74] Following this revelation, Cable had his responsibility for media affairs including ruling on Murdoch's takeover plans withdrawn from his role as business secretary. [43], It was fined 30,000 in 2015 for "sending an unsolicited email to hundreds of thousands of its subscribers, urging them to vote for the Conservatives. We make intelligent predictions, bold plans and rational decisions. Get in touch at clementine.cuneo@news.com.au. Information storage and access. @daveobigbro David Bonaddio Liana Boss Reporter Liana Boss is a journalist at The Northern Star and Byron Shire News. Miranda is currently in New York covering current affairs for The Daily Telegraph. Andrew English Daily Telegraph Motoring correspondent. [96], The paper published premature obituaries for Cockie Hoogterp, the second wife of Baron Blixen,[97] Dave Swarbrick in 1999,[97] and Dorothy Southworth Ritter, the widow of Tex Ritter and mother of John Ritter, in August 2001. Buy Search Sell www.buysearchsell.com.au [93] Most of these findings pertained to inaccuracy, as with other UK newspapers. In November 1940, Fleet Street, with its close proximity to the river and docklands, was subjected to almost daily bombing raids by the Luftwaffe and The Telegraph started printing in Manchester at Kemsley House (now The Printworks entertainment venue), which was run by Camrose's brother Kemsley. Opinion Coronavirus Cunard is an important Telegraph advertiser. Nationwide News Pty Ltd 2023. The Electronic Telegraph launched in 1995 with The Daily Telegraph Guide to the Internet'[26] by writer Sue Schofield for an annual charge of 180.00. The Telegraph has had a number of news scoops, including the outbreak of World War II by rookie reporter Clare Hollingworth, described as "the scoop of the century",[11] the 2009 MP expenses scandal which led to a number of high-profile political resignations and for which it was named 2009 British Newspaper of the Year[12] and its 2016 undercover investigation on the England football manager Sam Allardyce. [81] The Telegraph won "Team of the Year" in 2004 for its coverage of the Iraq War. Chris is Chief Operating Officer at The Telegraph, with responsibility for Technology, Digital products, newspaper operations and sales, along with print subscriptions, the services department and strategic projects. eventually being editor for three years from 1986. Enough water has flowed into the ocean from South Australia in the past three months to support all of regional NSW for a year and our state deserves a better deal, writes Water Minister Melinda Pavey. If you are a digital marketing company and send in a request, this will be ignored. 1860 The paper moves from The Strand to 135 Fleet Street. Fair-play: We are committed to the rule of law, respect for heritage and equality of opportunity. Tijana Birdjan is a reporter for NewsLocal, joining in late 2022 at the Dubbo News. The competition itself was won by F. H. W. Hawes of Dagenham who finished the crossword in less than eight minutes. Subscription Queries. Drive it to work, drive it home, plug it in and repeat. Fri 28 Nov 2008 06.26 EST. to leave the club with Moore the same evening. She has been at the masthead since 2017 and worked across general news, features, lifestyle and entertainment before taking on the health round during the Covid 19 pandemic. Festival fever is in full swing in one city, but motorists are warned to look out for large crowds and various road closures. Peta Credlin Columnist. [83], In 2014, The Telegraph designed a Newspaper-themed Paddington Bear statue, one of fifty located around London prior to the release of the film Paddington, which was auctioned to raise funds for the National Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Children (NSPCC). Chris studied at Edinburgh University and holds an MBA from Ashridge Business School. In May 2009, the daily and Sunday editions published details of MPs' expenses. [92], In January 2017, the Telegraph Media Group had a higher number of upheld complaints than any other UK newspaper by its regulator IPSO. Prior to joining the Telegraph, Catherine worked at the Daily Mail as a sub-editor. It was founded by Arthur B. Sleigh in 1855 as The Daily Telegraph & Courier. Before joining The Telegraph he was Yahoos Vice President for EMEA where he was responsible for all business and operations in EMEA markets, a role which he was promoted to in 2015 having previously worked as Yahoos EMEA vice president of audience network and programmatic platforms. [41], During the 2019 Conservative leadership election, The Daily Telegraph endorsed their former columnist Boris Johnson. [55], The Telegraph has published articles which have been criticised by PinkNews as transphobic. My Tributes www.mytributes.com.au, Switchboard (02) 9288 3000Submit an enquiry related to The Daily Telegraph here, Very often our readers are in the right place at the right time. The editorial grid was supplemented by an initial Factiva . But in Wagga? Sam Flanagan is the Afternoon Digital Editor of The Daily Telegraph and has worked in newsrooms throughout Queensland, Tasmania and New South Wales. Read the latest Tim Blair blog. His experience spans newspapers, consumer magazines, business-to-business media, and digital products. Madeleine started with the Daily Telegraph in 2020 and is currently studying a Master of Journalism. He joined the business in 2007, and was previously News Editor and Head of News. [67] As of December 2010, "Telegraph.co.uk" was the third most visited British newspaper website with 1.7million daily browsers compared to 2.3million for "Guardian.co.uk" and nearly 3 million for "Mail Online". Reporter Tessa Flemming has worked as a News Corp journalist for the past two years. The Daily Telegraph, known online and elsewhere as The Telegraph, is a national British daily broadsheet newspaper published in London by Telegraph Media Group and distributed across the United Kingdom and internationally. The Times is up 8.61%. Syndication is the licensing and copyright department of the Telegraph Media Group Limited. Matters that cannot be resolved there will be escalated to the Editor, the commercial director and the chief financial officer. [citation needed] Levy appointed his son, Edward Levy-Lawson, Lord Burnham, and Thornton Leigh Hunt to edit the newspaper. full details of the error, article link (if online), or page number and date of article. She began her career in regional journalism with the Tweed Daily News in 2013 and has also worked for the Stanthorpe Border Post. On 18 January 2004, Black was dismissed as chairman of the Hollinger International board over allegations of financial wrongdoing. [14] Levy took over the newspaper, his aim being to produce a cheaper newspaper than his main competitors in London, the Daily News and The Morning Post, to expand the size of the overall market. All times AEDT (GMT +11). Article suggestions and news tip offs form. He studied English at the University of Oxford. Michael Cain is a news reporter for the Newcastle News. However, the Daily Telegraph had been granted an invitation to the event. [45] The Telegraph wrote in another editorial that same year that it feared that changing "the law on gay marriage risks inflaming anti-homosexual bigotry". [20] In 1939, The Telegraph published Clare Hollingworth's scoop that Germany was to invade Poland.[21]. We shall be guided by a high tone of independent action. Matthew Benns is Editor-at-Large at The Daily Telegraph. David Bonaddio is a journalist for the Daily Telegraph based in Tweed Heads with a passion for podcasting and multimedia content. Internationally banks were also feeling the pressure of a troubled global economy with Goldman Sachs set to sack 3200 staff in one of its biggest round of job cuts in its more than 150-year history. She has an extensive career in police, crime and general news reporting - in Australia and internationally. Emily Burley is a reporter for The Sunday Telegraph. She joined News Corp in 2007 and has since held senior editorial roles at the Daily Telegraph, NewsLocal and the National News Network. [106] As of April 2020, The Telegraph appeared to have removed China Watch from its website, along with another advertisement feature section by a Chinese state-run media outlet titled "People's Daily Online". If you are looking for a back issue of The Daily Telegraph or The Sunday Telegraph, please contact: Web: backissuenewspapers.co.uk Tel: 0844 669 9400 Hyperlinking in articles If you are a. Find out more about our policy and your choices, including how to opt-out. While India is set to achieve the targets by 2030 on some indicators like full vaccination, electricity access, personal bank accounts and multi-dimensional poverty, there are a number of other target. He has previously worked at The Economist and Fulham Football Club. They must have senior editorial executive signoff before they are agreed. Ad selection, delivery, reporting. On 2 September 2008, the Daily Telegraph was printed with colour on each page for the first time when it left Westferry for Newsprinters at Broxbourne, Hertfordshire, another arm of the Murdoch (Rupert Murdoch) company. Liana Boss is a journalist at The Northern Star and Byron Shire News. Our Executive team, led by the Chief Executive Officer, Nick Hugh, is responsible for shaping and delivering the long-term strategy of The Telegraph, at the heart of which are our valued employees and customers. Lord Burnham relaunched the paper as The Daily Telegraph, with the slogan "the largest, best, and cheapest newspaper in the world". The partygate inquiry has been attacked as a "plot" by allies of Boris Johnson after Sue Gray stepped down from the Civil Service to become Sir Keir Starmer's chief of staff. Stories for our Investigations Team that need a higher level of security can be submitted here. ], The Daily Telegraph, in particular its columnist and former editor Charles Moore, were staunch supporters of Owen Paterson, a former MP and minister who resigned after it was found that he had breached advocacy rules to lobby ministers for fees. All times AEDT (GMT +11). "[49], Also in 2015, The Telegraph published its "Out at Work" list, naming "the top 50 list of LGBT executives".[50][importance? Mark has a masters degree in human resource management from Middlesex University, and a bachelors degree from Queen Mary and Westfield College, University of London. [5] Nevertheless, the first edition stressed the quality and independence of its articles and journalists:[7]. Highlights from her career of more than 20 years at News Corp and The Courier-Mail include interviewing two members of the Buffy cast, attending one of Steve Jobs' famous presentations, playing Super Mario with the man who created him, and writing about everything from flying cars to space junk lasers. [28] The new office features a "hub and spoke" layout for the newsroom to produce content for print and online editions. The paper told MPs they believe climate change is happening and humans play a role in it. Prior to this he was the companys Chief Operating Officer, a role he held for six months having joined the company in January 2017. Tim is a columnist and blogger for the Daily Telegraph. The Daily Telegraph has two key editorial meetings per day (10am and 2pm) and the print deadline for the newspaper is 8pm, though there are rolling deadlines for later editions after this. Former AAP newswire crime and regional NSW reporter. The Telegraph justified the publication of the information because it contended that the official information due to be released would have omitted key information about redesignating of second-home nominations. Nick has an MBA from INSEAD France, one of the leading business schools in the world, and a BA Hons degree from Manchester, England. The Daily Telegraph works separately to all other News Corp mastheads, although there are Network reporters. An early coup for the site was the publication of articles by Ambrose Evans-Pritchard on Bill Clinton and the Whitewater controversy. Alexi Demetriadi is a NSW State Parliament Reporter at News Corp Australia's Regional & Community Network. Prior to joining The Telegraph Mike worked at Guardian News and Media as Football Editor. She also contributes to Vogue, Vogue Living and GQ. [79] This led to a number of high-profile resignations from both the ruling Labour administration and the Conservative opposition. Measurement. [29] The paper is also printed in Liverpool and Glasgow by Newsprinters. [103] In their apology they said: "The article was published by our client following receipt of information in good faith from the Scout Association and the Henry Jackson Society; nevertheless our client now accepts that the article (using that expression to refer to both print and online versions) is defamatory of your client and will apologise to him for publishing it. Personalisation. The paper's motto, "Was, is, and will be", appears in the editorial pages and has featured in every edition of the newspaper since 19 April 1858. He has previously worked for the Telegraph, where he was Head of Sport during the 2012 Olympics and went on to be Executive Editor. We are creative and pioneering, and we are not afraid to fail in pursuit of innovation. All payments to staff and contributors for the creation of commercial content must be approved by their line manager in advance in writing. Letters for publication in The Daily Telegraph can be emailed to dtletters@telegraph.co.uk. Heffer has written two columns a week for the paper since late October 2005 and is a regular contributor to the news podcast. She is passionate about breaking news and serving her audience. Former Belfast Telegraph editor Roy Lilley: his job required great personal courage in the midst of extreme violence. Wendy Fitzgibbon is currently Audience Head of Strategy at the Daily Telegraph and oversees all of the masthead's digital and social platforms. Cormacs most recent role was CFO of JPI Media in London. Content selection, delivery, reporting. [121][additional citation(s) needed], This article is about the British newspaper. 008438828 of 2 Holt St, Surry Hills NSW 2010, at 26-52 Hume Highway, Chullora. Cormac is Chief Finance Officer with responsibility for the overall financial management of The Telegraph, as well as Procurement, Pensions, and Legal. Where any complaint under the FT Editorial Code is unable to be. [34] Even when Conservative support was shown to have slumped in the opinion polls and Labour gained the ascendant, the newspaper remained loyal to the Conservatives. On December 10 1919 the crew of a Vickers Vimy twin engine plane touched down to complete the Great Air Race, a London to Darwin aviation challenge that was then the worlds longest ever air journey. [54], Also in 2016, Telegraph Executive Director Lord Black was awarded Peer of the Year at the 2016 PinkNews Awards for his campaigning on LGBT rights. Keeping track of the major industry moves in his weekly column. Chris started his career in Bristol at news agency, South West News Service, which he joined after leaving Oxford University. The Daily Mail's star columnist and political analyst Simon Heffer left that paper in October 2005 to rejoin The Daily Telegraph, where he has become associate editor. Paul Crawley is a senior rugby league journalist for The Daily Telegraph and CODE Sports. He has spent 15 years focused on technology in the media industry, and 10 of those years as a media executive. For help with print and digital subscriptions, including purchasing a subscription please contact: I have seen it from the inside", "Police called in after Scout group run from mosque is linked to Islamic extremist and Holocaust denier", "A British Newspaper Has Given Chinese Coronavirus Propaganda A Direct Line To The UK", "Inside China's audacious global propaganda campaign", "Toby Young: Telegraph coronavirus column 'significantly misleading', "Daily Telegraph rebuked over Toby Young's Covid column", "Telegraph article on climate change mixes accurate and unsupported, inaccurate claims, misleads with false balance", "The Telegraph publishes false information about Arctic climate", "Analysis of "How Arctic ice has made fools of all those poor warmists", "Analysis of "Earth heading for 'mini ice age' within 15 years", "Analysis of "in many ways global warming will be a good thing", "Who speaks climate making sense media reporting climate change | Comparative politics", "Telegraph and Mail concede on climate change", "Covid: Boris Johnson resisted autumn lockdown as only over-80s dying - Dominic Cummings", "Boris Johnson's bruising defeat over standards reform angers Tory MPs", William Ewart Berry, 1st Viscount Camrose, https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=The_Daily_Telegraph&oldid=1142364055, This page was last edited on 2 March 2023, at 00:29. Notable previous positions include Chief Operating Officer for News UK and Chief Information Officer for Emap. [40], In the 2016 United Kingdom European Union membership referendum it endorsed voting to leave the EU. [97], Editors for both the Daily Telegraph and the Sunday Telegraph have been criticised by Guardian columnist Owen Jones for publishing and authoring articles which espouse an anti-Semitic conspiracy theory. [42] In 2019, former columnist Graham Norton, who had left the paper in late 2018, said "about a year before I left, it took a turn" and criticised it for "toxic" political stances, namely for a piece defending US Supreme Court then-nominee Brett Kavanaugh and for being "a mouthpiece for Boris Johnson" whose columns were allegedly published with "no fact-checking at all". Circulation of The Sunday Telegraph in July 2010 was 505,214 (ABC). Energy price guarantee to be extended for three months. She was previously a federal political reporter at the Daily Telegraph, and has also reported for the Townsville Bulletin. The paper paid Hussain damages and costs. Oborne accused the paper of a "form of fraud on its readers"[89] for its coverage of the bank HSBC in relation to a Swiss tax-dodging scandal that was widely covered by other news media. [62] The site is overseen by Kate Day,[63] digital director of Telegraph Media Group. The editorial board endorsed the Conservative Party in the 2005 general election. The Editors decision on the use of editorial placements in relation to a campaign shall be final. Despite the recent heavy rains and many dams full or close to capacity, there is no room for complacency in ensuring the future water supply of all NSW communities, ANY year where we didnt open any new mines is a lost year for the Northern Territory, writes DREW WAGNER. Thames Water forces smart water meters on households without their knowledge, The SNP is tearing itself apart and its delicious to watch, Neil Gourley targeting Jakob Ingebrigtsen scalp after narrow 1,500m second, Boris Johnson manipulated by Matt Hancock into backing lockdowns, claims whistleblower, How Tesco and Sainsbury's obsession with Aldi fuelled Britain's fruit and vegetable rationing crisis. All times AEDT (GMT +11). These include Telegraph deputy editor Hunt, feature writer and author Wallop, Daily and Sunday Telegraph Middle East . Subscriber Support We do not add links to articles retrospectively. Commercial staff should not influence editorials story judgments in connection with any advertisers or potential advertisers interest. It is paid a further 750,000 a year for a similar arrangement with the Chinese state in relation to the pro-Beijing China Watch advertising supplement. Weekly column. He covers World Cups and Wimbledon, Ashes and Olympics, rugby league and football. In the late 1930s, Victor Gordon Lennox, The Telegraph's diplomatic editor, published an anti-appeasement private newspaper The Whitehall Letter that received much of its information from leaks from Sir Robert Vansittart, the Permanent Under-Secretary of the Foreign Office, and Rex Leeper, the Foreign Office's Press Secretary. She has previously worked at The Daily Telegraph as an online producer and reporter for a range of News Corp titles. [90] Later that month, Telegraph editor Chris Evans invited journalists at the newspaper to contribute their thoughts on the issue. [34][35] The personal links between the paper's editors and the leadership of the Conservative Party, along with the paper's generally right-wing stance and influence over Conservative activists, have led the paper commonly to be referred to, especially in Private Eye, as the Torygraph. Last year his energies went into breaking one of the biggest sport stories for the Daily Telegraph, uncovering a grooming culture which exists in women's football in Australia. D&I Contact Us Our people Our Executive team, led by the Chief Executive Officer, Nick Hugh, is responsible for shaping and delivering the long-term strategy of The Telegraph, at the heart of. He previously spent more than 15 years at various internet companies, including BT and ad tech specialist Phorm. The Daily Telegraph and Courier is founded by Colonel Arthur B. Sleigh in June 1855. The Telegraph Investigations team has published a series of ground-breaking scoops that have held the powerful to account. Black was also sued by the company. Catherine joined the organisation in 2008 and has held the positions of Chief Production Journalist, Deputy Editor of the Telegraph website, Head of Digital News and Assistant Editor, before moving into her current role. The Telegraph began publishing, in instalments from 8 May 2009, certain MPs' expenses.[78]. In undertaking such tasks, journalists should do nothing to compromise their ability to write for our audience objectively, fairly and honestly. Together The Daily Telegraph, printed and published by the proprietor, Nationwide News Pty Ltd A.C.N. Welcome to motoring.telegraph.co.uk. In a way, they are right to be, because attacking people for their personal preferences can be a nasty thing. Jeremy Hunt will announce the move in his Budget on March 15 to stop bills from rising following a high profile campaign by Martin Lewis . [according to whom?] We take full ownership of our work and results. She covers all sports, but is particularly passionate about netball, rugby league and rugby union. He reports on issues relating to crime and court, development, council, education, health and transport. Fearless Dylan Arvela is a journalist based in Wollongong, reporting for The Illawarra Star and The Daily Telegraph. Our purpose is to champion, through quality journalism, our core beliefs of enterprise, fair play and enjoyment. Odessa Blain is the local digital reporter for the Hills Shire Times and Hornsby Advocate. The Young Telegraph was a weekly section of The Daily Telegraph published as a 14-page supplement in the weekend edition of the newspaper. He spent 11 years at the Daily Mail, spending stints as a general reporter and in the Femail department before becoming News Editor. He has led technology transformation, digital product innovation, operational services (including print production and distribution), and has variously owned both digital product and B2B service P&Ls. Pricing; API; Companies; . Learn more Australia Between 2011-2016 editorial articles in publications such as the Sun, the Daily Telegraph and the Daily Mail generally opposed action to tackle climate change, citing "unreliable" science .