Many opted to not make a quarterback the 46th man on game day. Really dumb not to have enough players at the most important position in the game. Now, the 49ers have seen enough, inviting questions about Rosens future in the NFL. But hey, maybe the 49ers can sell Minshew on getting a few starts, winning some games and then moving on to another opportunity after a one-year deal. Even with a slightly sore foot he could have done more than Purdy out there with his arm like linguini. Keenum has long been one of the NFL's better backup quarterbacks. However, the 49ers hope Purdy can buck those trends. But Brock has been thrust into the starting role in Would it really have mattered if they had a 3rd? You chose to dress 2 qbs and not 3. Active players are listed in bold.. That is NOT normal, and NOT a fluke. The 49ers plan to look for another inside linebacker with Wilhelm gone. Terms at draftkings.com/sportsbook. Singletary said he has watched Brock improve every day in practice. Both the 49ers and Garoppolo are ready to move on from one another. White played for both, and it's likely that LaFleur's offense has at leastsomesimilarities to that of Shanahan. Ya think? "We won a lot of football games with Jimmy. That became a blessing in disguise when Lance went down with a Week 2 leg injury, as Garoppolo helped steady the ship and kept the 49ers in the postseason race. Broadcast and streaming information for the San Francisco 49ers Divisional Round matchup against the Dallas Cowboys at Levi's Stadium. He led the Saints to a 6-8 record in his starts despite having a dearth of receiving weapons at his disposal. Why isn't Jimmy Garoppolo among them? !!! He is also much more raw, having started just 17 games at the FCS level during his college days. MORE: Latest injury updates on Brock Purdy after QB suffers torn ACL. Granted, most of the losses came during his time in Jacksonville, but it's worth noting that he is just 1-3 in four starts with the Eagles. As an Eagles fan, I can tell you that the thought of CMC in wildcat running weird, undiagnosable plays with Deebo in end arounds, reverses, and flea flickers actually scared me more than the thought of Purdy simply handing off to play out the string. Josh Johnson is the 49ers backup quarterback against the Philadelphia Eagles in the NFC Championship. And teams will dress only 2 QBs again. So What ? However, he has been with the 49ers since 2017 and has posted a 31-14 record as their starter. Davis to be 49ers' third-string QB after surviving final cuts. They already have two young quarterbacks in Purdy (23) and Lance (22), so adding someone to replace Jimmy Garoppolo (31) in that role would be ideal. But the NFL product sucks when one team doesnt have a QB. There was nothing stopping them from carrying three QBs on Sunday. Did any of you read the article??? They ran one play like that until Purdy could take the field and it gained chunk yardage. He is a good play caller but his play designs leave his quarterbacks out to dry, 2017- Hoyer (5), Beathard (6), Jimmy (5) Brock Purdy suffered an elbow injury. Thats his m.o. It would likely lead to either a similar game plan that that the 49ers followed with running the ball, or worsethe 3rd quarterback being a liability with sacks, turnovers and false start penalties (e.g. He was able to return to action for three must-win 49ers games, but between that and a shoulder problem that landed him on the injury report last week, he may not be quite 100 percent for the rest of the NFL season. Unbelievable. Broadcast and streaming information for the San Francisco 49ers vs. Philadelphia Eagles NFC Championship Game at Lincoln Financial Field. Shortly afterward, he was traded to the Dolphins for a package of draft picks. He entered the game in the first quarter after an injury to Brock Purdy, who eventually returned in the third quarter. You go out there, you prepare as best you can, you get better every single day at practice, and once you get your opportunity, man, its what are you going to do with it? I remember the Niners years ago had Cody Pickett playing on the punt team as the personal protector. Seriously, just dont dress that 53rd guy on your roster. 2022- Trey (2), Jimmy (10), Purdy (5), Johnson & back to Purdy Lol. The 49ers just capped their first unbeaten preseason since going 5-0 in 1992. Chad Reuter provides a stock report from Indianapolis. Well colts carried 3 at times on the roster this yr we still didnt have a good one but we had 3 on the roster. Doh! Lets not change the rule books over one teams misfortunes for one season . Brock Purdy didn't need to put this team on his back to win and neither would Trey Lance. As a Niner fan, listen up. Updated Oct 11, 2021 at 9:58pm Getty Jimmy Garoppolo #10 and Trey Lance #5 of the San Francisco 49ers. for 2,786 yds. The 49ers did open their season with 3 QBs on their roster, not necessarily their active roster. During the season-ending press conference in Santa Clara, the question of the now-defunct third-quarterback rule came up. There is no reason to have a game time roster and to have a full roster. Both of his siblings are also athletes. Among 49ers quarterbacks with 500 passing attempts, Garoppolo ranks first in completion percentage (67.7) and second in passer rating (98.3) behind Steve Young (101.4). Its not his fault these actions resulted in injuries but could it be his fault that he puts his players in these positions which increase the risk they might get hurt? It is highly recommended that you use the latest versions of a supported browser in order to receive an optimal viewing experience. He helped guide the team to a Super Bowl 54 appearance and threw for 3,810 yards, 20 touchdowns and 12 interceptions during the 2021 NFL season. Jimmy Garoppolo will be picked up by a different team in desperate need of a veteran quarterback, Trey Lance is still in recovery from his injury last year and Brock Purdy who also suffered a UCL injury in the conference championship game delayed his surgery to commit to becoming a starter in 2023. Dae says: Purdy is just two wins away from becoming the first rookie quarterback to win the Super Bowl, one win from being the first to even appear in one. (66.9 pct.) I imagine McDaniel runs the same offense in Miami still which makes me wonder why Shanahan offenses injure QBs so often. I mean, if they change the rule and make it available, fine. I think itd be good for football, G.M. Figures are sorted by number of wins. Here's what you need to know about Garoppolo's backup and the other quarterback options further down the 49ers' depth chart. Another rule is not needed when a team cant do better than what I saw in this melt down.You could mandate 5 cannon fodder Q.B.s for the grist mill. But playoff football hits differently. The 49ers designed some running packages for the mobile Lance early in the season, but they haven't used them as much of late. Currently, Garoppolo is dealing with a thumb injury in his throwing hand that caused him to miss Week 17. Marcus Mariota 3. I think hes taken a couple of steps back the last few practices. The Bucs did not opt to move the pocket passer onto their roster to stop the 49ers from adding him to theirs. After being the last pick in the 2022 Draft, Brock joined the San Francisco 49ers as the third-string quarterback. NFL=WWE. He's a big-time playmaker," defensive coordinator DeMeco Ryans said during Day 2 of training camp. We dont need a 3rd quarterback rule. Broadcast and streaming information for the San Francisco 49ers Week 17 matchup against the Las Vegas Raiders at Allegiant Stadium. "I think he understands more now the degree that he has to work at it, becoming an NFL quarterback. Obviously, former 49ers first-round pick Trey Lance would currently start in Purdys place, but theres an entire offseason for San Francisco to shake up their quarterback room. After taking over from Jimmy Garoppolo as the 49ers quarterback, he's led them on a stunning win streak, San Francisco 49ers rookie quarterback Brock Purdy celebrates after winning his playoff debut last weekend, A look at San Francisco 49ers quarterback Brock Purdy's best plays from his debut playoff game against the Seattle Seahawks, San Francisco 49ers quarterback Brock Purdy had a wholesome reaction to LeBron James shouting him out on Twitter after a stellar debut playoff performance, Highlights of the Dallas Cowboys against the San Francisco 49ers in the Divisional Round of the NFL playoffs. That's certainly a sensible move. WebObviously, former 49ers first-round pick Trey Lance would currently start in Purdys place, but theres an entire offseason for San Francisco to shake up their quarterback room. The final pick in the 2022 NFL Draft, Purdy had an exceptional rookie season. Even if San Francisco's defense plays great, the Eagles are still going to score at least 20 points on offense.". _________________. Purdy immediately led the Niners on a 54-yard scoring drive, capped with a touchdown pass to Kyle Juszczyk, and then added another 76-yard touchdown drive just before the half - this one ended with a scoring strike to Christian McCaffrey - to give San Francisco a lead they would not relinquish. Lance was a one-year starter at North Dakota State, but he led the team to an FCS Championship and completed. It wasn't sharp early on - he left some plays on the field.". 1-800-547-6133 (WA). Shanahan was down to his fourth QB and McDaniels nearly got Tua killed in Miami. Not saying it wouldve won SF the game, but it certainly wouldve made it more interesting. Lets just say, for arguments sake, that they did have a third guy ready to go. Jacob Camenker is a senior content producer at The Sporting News. The last person you picked for the roster would be a backup on special teams that never saw the game. I think he understands and he still does that, 'I really have to get this thing down, I really have to have control of the offense.' The 49ers traded up to the No. He is Brock Purdy. Manage. When they expanded the schedule to 17 games they shouldve allowed for 53 men to be dressed on gameday. I would be curious as to how many times this 46th player actually plays in a game. Another genius idea that would develop players at a position under the guise of equity, while being ultimately racist and discriminating but perfectly okay because it only effects White males looking for the very same opportunity. I just go out there, and I just play., Related: The way 49ers New Customer Offer (if applicable). 49ers QB options, ranked (Getty Images) 1. 3 overall pick in the 2021 NFL Draft. As a result, San Francisco kept Garoppolo. And when Garoppolo suffered a (potentially) season-ending injury in Week 13, Brock Purdy moved from backup to starter. On this day, the San Francisco 49ers defeated the Denver Broncos 55-10 in Super Bowl XXIV. The 49ers released 22 players on Friday, but all their 2010 draft picks made the cut. Coaches wouldnt use the extra active spots to rest players or maintain a suitable reserve capability, but to create even more highly specialized packages, sub-packages, and sub-sub-packages for defense, gadget players for offense, and super-specialists for situation downs. We were supposed to go to someone and we had a busted route, so then it kind of fell apart and he tried to overcompensate and he made a bad situation worse.. With both Brock Purdy and Josh Johnson going down with injuries, the 49ers were forced to employ running back Christian McCaffrey at quarterback. How about a breakdown of snap counts to show how dumb teams are in not properly assembling rosters. WebRT @PTulini: I don't want to hear anything about "win now mode" when the #49ers just had a 3rd string rookie quarterback lead them into the playoffs. The special teams captain had spent all four of his NFL seasons with San Francisco. Purdy is a rookie this year, picked last - 262nd - in the 2022 NFL Draft and set as the third string quarterback for the Niners. Even while Purdy, a quarterback drafted seven rounds after Lance, quickly established himself as a reliable starter under center, the former No. However, Garoppolo was rehabbing a shoulder injury, and that prevented the 49ers from finding a suitable trade offer for him. Man Utd revive interest in Barcelona star De Jong, Klopp, Ten Hag ask for 'tragedy chanting' to end ahead of Liverpool vs Man Utd, PL Predictions: Chelsea to draw another blank vs Leeds, What is Chelsea's best XI? They also boast a plethora of weapons on offense, with Purdy able to pick and choose from the likes of McCaffrey at running back - a mid-season steal via trade with the Carolina Panthers - as well as dual-threat receiver Deebo Samuel and tight end George Kittle, the heartbeat of the team. 4 of the 6 years shanahan has been coach we have started our 3rd string quarterback at least 5 games. After all, remember that SF was starting QB3, with QB4 as a back-up. The second part of the issue is that Minshew is only 26. Is there a bigger choker than Shanahan? "Where I think this matchup is different to last week against the Cowboys, I got the sense in the game that it was a conservative game plan from the 49ers. MORE: Why Joe Montana thinks 49ers should start Jimmy Garoppolo in 2023. But now, Garoppolo is ready to go to a team where he will have a chance to compete for a legitimate, long-term starting job. I think he started off real well, Shanahan said on Sunday. That includes an 0-2 in 2022 despite having a Super Bowl-level supporting cast. The 49ers had to go to QB No. Act like a coach. February 1, 2023 at 8:29 pm. Call 1-800-GAMBLER (DC, IL, LA, MD, MS, NJ, OH, PA, TN, WV, WY, VA), Call 1-800-NEXT-STEP (AZ), 1-800-522-4700 (CO, KS, NV), 1-800-BETS-OFF (IA), 1-800-270-7117 for confidential help (MI), Call 877-8-HOPENY or text HOPENY (467369) (NY). AMNY Newsletter. Sudfeld was originally drafted by the Washington Commanders in the sixth-round (187th overall) of the 2016 NFL Draft. Sporting immortality awaits for San Francisco 49ers quarterback Brock Purdy. The NFL playoffs continue this weekend with Championship Sunday. At some point you have to ask yourself if your offense is creating situations where the QBs can get hurt and maybe make some changes. Hollywood Life I guess a better question is why Garappolo wasnt active since they only thing he said he couldnt do is sprint. traded to the Dolphins for a package of draft picks. ==================, frankgorever says: itendtoknowitall says: San Francisco selected Lance out of North Dakota Statewith the No. Purdy tore a tendon in his elbow on the 49ers first possession. It's easy to imagine that he would be. But since the 49ers have two banged-up quarterbacks and went through injury issues last year, they may be more likely to stay away from the 30-year-old. For me, I believe in the Lord, and I trust in Him, the athlete said. AMNY Newsletter. Worth a thought. Brock Purdy, 23, is having a fairytale experience in the NFL right now. That said, general manager John Lynch explained at the 2023 NFL Combine that the team is exploring insurance options at the position. 4 on this list? Youre always trying to develop these guys, but youre always weighing that carrying three as opposed to the roster value of being able to host a full complement of position players at different positions, so I think if the league just kind of gave you an out there, everybody would be forced to do it. Brock has an older sister, Whitney Purdy, and a younger brother, Chubba Purdy. "I'm just thankful for the opportunity to have him be in front of me," Lance said. He uses very few doubles or chips from backs, etc., choosing instead to emphasize maximum receivers in the pattern. All unquestionable superstars at their respective positions. In other words, exactly where we are now, just with more people. If your qb gets hurt after halftime then you dont get a backup. The only thing he could do was either hand the ball off or throw screens to McCaffrey. It didn't go well for either as the 49ers built a 17-3 lead before the Eagles scored late. A group of UK Faithful traveled overseas to get a behind-the-scenes tour and experience a 49ers win at Levi's Stadium. The San Francisco 49ers had another strong season in 2022, once again reaching the NFC Championship Game, albeit under different circumstances, as the team was down WebWho should the #49ers consider signing as the 3rd string quarterback from this list? He can run a franchise as well as anyone and better than most. Trey has done an excellent job these first two days.". There could easily be situations where one team does not have 53 healthy players available, leading to a competitive mismatch. I bet they wouldwasnt Garapolo suited up for the game last weekend? Call 1-800-GAMBLER. And why wouldnt it? And considering the 49ers' luck at QB in recent memory, his tenure as a starter could be more of an extended period of time. What is ridiculous is anyone arguing that having a third QB would have made a difference for the Niners on Sunday. He Beathard threw three His career .702 winning percentage as a starting QB is the fourth-highest among active NFL quarterbacks. Philly lead the league in sacks. January 31, 2023 at 7:22 am "He was playing at a high level in training camp last year and I think it's the same thing this year. It would probably behoove him to join a team planning to draft a rookie rather than going to a squad with two young passers. Brock lead the team to a win and even threw a touchdown. With both Brock Purdy and Josh Johnson going down with injuries, the 49ers were forced to employ running back Christian McCaffrey at quarterback. he 49ers' third-string quarterback Brock Purdy stepped into the starting lineup against the Miami Dolphins after Jimmy Garoppolo suffered a broken foot that ended his 2022 NFL season. If the 49ers were smart theyd have dressed three. Rosen did not appear in a game during the 2020 season, splitting time between the Buccaneers practice squad and the 49ers roster. February 1, 2023 at 11:25 pm, What does an arbitrary limit of 46 provide? And I like the idea of teams having the opportunity to add a Taysom Hill, Kordell Stewart, Randel El guy. Strengthening his skills ahead of the new season, the second-year quarterback continues to take every opportunity he has to continue to master Kyle Shanahan's complex offensive scheme. 66.9 percent of his passes for 2,786 yards, 28 touchdowns and no interceptions. Besides, what could adding the extra QB roster spot possibly hurt? WebRT @PTulini: I don't want to hear anything about "win now mode" when the #49ers just had a 3rd string rookie quarterback lead them into the playoffs. We were scared to death when that rule ended, whatever many years ago that was, but you kind of forget about it since you just dont see anyone have to go through it, but then you get reminded of how quickly a football game is over once that happens, so I think that would be a very smart thing to have.. Why stop there? The new nfl protocol is taking any concussion player out for the game. So, basically, a return of the rule would result in a 47th man a third quarterback being in uniform. Or do dress him and risk playing without a QB. 49ers may have to look into QB market to support Brock Purdy, Trey Lance. Who is the 49ers' backup quarterback? First-bet offers not valid in Ohio. SANTA CLARA, Calif. -- Nate Davis is receiving a chance to keep Whats the harm in having an athletic QB on the roster who could play special teams or WR/DB in a pinch? Every year some team loses in the playoffs and every year they advocate for a rule change.. how long till we just play Rock Paper Scissors.. until the rules get changed where rock breaks through paper. Of course, Watson was coming back from what was effectively a two-year layoff. Look, White is hardly an inspiring veteran quarterback option, but he's one that the 49ers could consider nonetheless. Bridgewater hasn't played a full NFL season since 2015. 12 spot and evaluated Lance, Justin Fields and Mac Jones as they considered a long-term replacement for Garoppolo. The only question is whether Brissett will look for a job that would offer him a better chance to earn a starting job long-term. Is there something about the Shanahan system that leaves the QBs exposed and more susceptible to getting hit? This year, Lance hopes to improve upon the 41 completed passes for 603 yards and five touchdowns he notched from starting in just two games last year. When you have two active quarterbacks on game day and they both get injured, you REALLY have none. The Chiefs got pretty thin at WR on Sunday, lets start allowing teams to carry extra WRs too. Broadcast and streaming information for the San Francisco 49ers Week 16 matchup against the Washington Commanders at Levi's Stadium. Im all for it, but the talent level and the preparedness of a 3rd quarterback wouldnt make it that significant. Perhaps the 49ers won't mind Bridgewater's track record considering that he would be in a less taxing role. Tramaine Brock, a third-string cornerback who picked off Jonathan Crompton's pass with 48 seconds left Thursday, made the team. Lance ended up being the choice. They werent going to win wtih Josh Johnson and they certainly werent going to win with whoever they would have had as third string. It also doesn't hurt to have Trent Williams blocking for you at left tackle. We use cookies and other tracking technologies to improve your browsing experience on our site, show personalized content and targeted ads, analyze site traffic, and understand where our audiences come from. The smartest replies of any thread Ive seen on here. 1. Lance will almost certainly be the 49ers' starter for the 2022 NFL season but Kyle Shanahan has been reluctant to throw him into action to date. God forbid allowing an extra player suit up for a game. Promotional offers not available in Nevada and New York. He might now never earn his spot back, with the fearless Purdy becoming the first rookie quarterback to win a playoff game since Russell Wilson with the Seahawks in 2012 - let alone two of them. The San Francisco 49ers, already missing Trey Lance and Jimmy Garoppolo, lost Brock Purdy to an injury in the NFC Championship Game. He may only have a record of 29-35 as a starter, but he put together an 11-3 record with the Vikings in 2017 and won each of his two starts with the Browns in 2021. With more protection for a QB than ever, at some point, somebody is going to question the 49ers strength and conditioning program for QBs. In a tight, cagey 19-12 game, turnovers were always going to be key, and ultimately it was Cowboys veteran QB Dak Prescott who coughed up two costly interceptions. Big time fail there by the niners. From Lance's perspective, Shanahan's pre-training camp statement didn't serve as an "aha" moment due to the fact that he's been keeping a starting-role mindset since being drafted by San Francisco in 2021. It was a freak occurrence. That is NOT normal, and NOT a fluke. Rewards issued as non-withdrawable bonus bets. When you have two quarterbacks, you have none. Juszczyk has taken snaps in gimmick formations but has never played quarterback at any level of football. As far as Im concerned we went into the ..NFC Championship : drum roll game.. with ONE Quarter Back. 12 XLIXLIXLI Patriots 4 yr. ago 4th string before camp cuts too 4 ReallyFnCleverName Chiefs 4 yr. ago Somewhere Tim Tebow is wondering why do people assume the QB has to throw the ball to win? Any team CAN dress a 3rd QB but 99% of the time its a waste, so few teams do it, unless the QB is a gadget player too. A better rule would be not to rely on back up TEs blocking a legit DPOY.